Makin Waves’ Record of Week: The Cryptkeeper Five’s ‘Stronghold’



The Cryptkeeper Five.

Veteran Trenton band The Cryptkeeper Five recently released “Stronghold,” their sixth album since 2002 and first in six years. After a month of celebrations in August, tasty shows will continue in September with a Happy Mondays gig on Sept. 11 at The Wonder Bar in Asbury Park and a couple of shows in Philly.

I can hear why these indie punk-rock veterans and the younger Asbury Park-based outfit The Vansaders have become friends and celebrated the release of their 
new records together, because they share and musically express a love of The Clash and Bruce Springsteen. On Stronghold — The Cryptkeeper Five’s sixth album, first in six years, and arguably their best yet — the band fuses those loves on the Celtic-tinged “Frankie,” which also owes a nod to Flogging Molly and Dropkick Murphys. The heartfelt, autobiographical tune about two wee brothers whose dysfunctional father gets a kick out of forcing them to box on their front lawn, combines Springsteen’s exceptional storytelling (as on the brotherly tale of “Highway
Patrolman”) with The Clash’s anthemic, one-for-all-and-all-for-one edge.

The 11-track collection opens with “MadDog 20/20 no. 2,” which sports Springsteen-like heartland expanse along the lines of “No Surrender,” one of many fine production moments captured by engineer Sean Glonek and vocalist-guitarist Johnny Ott. From the opening surf twang of “MadDog” to the rousing punk choral close of Jeff Mangum’s heartbreaking “Two-Headed Boy,” the pair provides just enough polish to make “Stronghold” a really well-made, vocally harmonic record, yet it maintains enough grit to keep the punks from getting turned off.

Great production often is in the tiny details, a factor that makes the exceptional songwriting and passionate performances of Stronghold even stronger. The isolated use of bells during a perfect pause on “1,000 Keys” is especially memorable, along with the muted trumpet of Christopher Tolomeo that brings the otherwise explosive “Bristol” to a touching close.

Inspired by “Rocky” (my all-time favorite movie), “Balboa” gives CK5 a chance to flex their Philly muscles and share their sense of humor. A bit more of the Springsteen influence, as well as that of Johnny Cash, comes out here with a reference to “ties that bind.”

Anyone in a band will appreciate the polarizing priorities of “East Horizon,” which expresses the exhausting balance of the infrequent time spent with a patient lover on the weary road to success. I particularly like the line “all the drinks and the girls and the drugs … don’t mean a thing to me … there’s only you,” as well as the dual lead vocal with bassist Michael Groch.

For rockabilly and punkabilly fans, there is the anthemic “Ignite,” which aims to set the world on fire with a hard heart, while the raging, vocally intense “Boulette” will appeal to Bowie fans. The band, also featuring guitarist Jimmy Harrington Jr. and drummer D.T. Graves, shines throughout “Stronghold,” but my favorite track may be “MadDog 20/20 no. 1,” which, despite its title, comes near the end of the record. A beautiful duet between Mott and “Amazing” Amy Matlack, his partner in the unplugged side project Wild Hearts Can’t Be Broken, makes this acoustic
version more emotionally stirring than the opening electric take. Given their distinctive strengths, however, I can understand why CK5 would want to use both because they emphasize different parts of a story about a struggling couple who need each other in order to stand tall and survive.

I often awake in the morning with a song on my mind. Lately, that’s been CK5’s closing cover of Mangum’s “The Diary of Anne Frank”-inspired “Two-Headed Boy” from his band Neutral Milk Hotel’s 2005 swan song, In the Aeroplane Over the Sea. Heartbreaking, like the original, the track also is original-sounding and extremely memorable because the arrangement suits the growls, screams and quivers of Ott’s dynamic voice and rich, rousing harmonies with his bandmates so well.

I also really like that The Cryptkeeper Five thought enough of Ott’s lyrics to invest in printing them on a trifold cardboard CD sleeve; their strength is well worth poring over. You can experience that live when CK5 play Happy Mondays on Sept. 11 at The Wonder Bar in Asbury Park with two other Trenton outfits, Meeko Brando and The Carousers. The band also will play Philly on Sept. 23 at Connie’s Ric Rac with The Accused and Sept. 29 at Century.

Bob Makin is the reporter for and a former
managing editor and still a contributor to The Aquarian Weekly, which launched this column in 1988. Contact him at Like Makin Waves at


Since launching in September 2014,, a 501(c)(3) organization, has become one of the most important media outlets for the Garden State arts scene. And it has always offered its content without a subscription fee, or a paywall. Its continued existence depends on support from members of that scene, and the state’s arts lovers. Please consider making a contribution of any amount to via PayPal, or by sending a check made out to to 11 Skytop Terrace, Montclair, NJ 07043.


Custom Amount

Personal Info

Donation Total: $20.00

Explore more articles:

Leave a Comment

Sign up for our Newsletter